Dairy/Cheese / Snacks

British Cheese and Onion Sandwich

I had the best sandwich of my life during my trip to the UK in June. And I’m slightly embarrassed to say that it was a cheese and red onion sandwich I bought from the M&S outlet at Gatwick Airport. I can’t begin to describe the sheer beauty of that sandwich: it was creamy, it was full of really good, honest cheese and the onions were so sweet and crunchy and my mouth is watering from just thinking about that sandwich.

Now obviously the sensible thing to do would be to try and recreate that sandwich. I’m pretty sure I’ve previously talked about how expensive cheeses are in Singapore and it took me quite a long time to get around to buying a good block of Red Leicester just so that I can make my own cheese and onion sandwich. I’m not sure whether you’re the sort of person who’d like cheese and onion together, though. I don’t usually see that many people going after the onions when I order from Subway (unless they’re the type to ask for all the vegetables; I’m a tomato, lettuce and onion person myself) and I would indeed advise you to brush your teeth after eating this. But I think the onions are a lovely, slightly spicy counterpart to the sharpness of the cheeses in this sandwich. Use a good, British cheese – Red Leicester and cheddar should be perfectly fine. As for the onions, I’d go with either red onions or sweet white onions. I’ve seen recipes online that grill the sandwich afterwards, which I think is completely unnecessary – this is not the British version of a grilled cheese sandwich. Some recipes also make use of salt, which I think is not required; the saltiness of the cheese should suffice, and I’m not exactly salt-phobic.

(One day, I will try and recreate the coronation chicken sandwich I ate in London. But that’ll probably take more time.)

British Cheese and Onion Sandwich
Serves 1, as a substantial snack or a light lunch

What you need

  • 50 g of grated cheese (a mixture of Red Leicester and mature white cheddar)
  • A quarter of a small red onion or sweet white onion, finely diced
  • 1 tbsp mayonnaise
  • Freshly ground black pepper, to taste
  • Butter

Place the cheese and onions in a bowl. Add the mayonnaise and a good helping of freshly ground black pepper. Mix everything thoroughly using a spoon. Butter two slices of untoasted bread (I suppose you could toast the bread if you really wanted to, but I think soft bread goes really well with the creamy, slightly lumpy texture of the sandwich filling) and spread the filling on the bread slices. Assemble the sandwich and then slice into two triangles. You can serve this with a light salad on the side or, if you’re short of time (like me), a couple of cherry tomatoes or a boiled egg.

5 thoughts on “British Cheese and Onion Sandwich

  1. Oh Amanda, you’ve got me salivating at the memory of that most wonderful M&S sandwich! It’s a huge pity they don’t sell it here. Does this taste similar enough? And where did you buy the cheese from?

    • To be honest I can’t remember what it exactly tastes like. *sighs* I got the cheese from Fairprice Finest. Would go to one of those small cheese shops but didn’t have the time then.

  2. I had a similar sandwich at the Horseshoe Pass tourist stop in Wales in 2002. I’ve dreamed of having another one ever since. Just yesterday I found true Welsh sharp cheese in an Aldi’s grocery store of all places, and I found your blog while looking for the cheese and onion sandwich recipe. Tomorrow I shall finally have my long awaited cheese and onion sandwich! 🙂

    And I can help you with the coronation chicken sandwich spread recipe…
    I had that at a potluck welcome luncheon while in England on the same choral performance trip in 2002, and fell in love with it. After a lot of searching to find out who brought the dish, I got a verbal recipe from the person who brought it.
    Start with white meat chicken (she used tinned chicken meat). Mix in Miracle Whip salad dressing until it’s the consistency you prefer for sandwich spread. Stir in curry powder, tasting often until it’s the strength you like. Add currants until it looks like chocolate chip cookie dough. Serve immediately, or let it sit in the refrigerator overnight for the currants to soften up and the curry flavor to intensify.

  3. This is terrific and being that you mentioned serving it with a hard boiled egg, think the egg could be incorporated into the cheese and onion mixture? I’m going to try it. It would be like having the best of both sandwiches!

  4. I made a cheese and onion sandwich with bbq source just not cook just like that it so nice you can tell the onions and bbq source not cheese but it take back when I made it at the old people home when I cook that sandwich for morning tea

Leave a Reply to Matthewholm Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s